Town vs town
answered from the site’s listings
Frequently asked
Is it better to stay in Key Largo or Islamorada?
Key Largo
1 answer
Oct 13, 2026
1 answer
In short
Going by the ratings of the hotels and inns in our listings, Key Largo edges it: its top three average 4.87★ against 4.43★ in Islamorada. Key Largo has 28 hotels and inns listed, Islamorada has 4.
Best rated on each side:
- Kona Kai Resort, Gallery and Botanic Gardens (4.9★), Key Largo
- Sea Dwellers Dive Center of Key Largo (4.8★), Key Largo
- Paradise Island Charters (4.9★), Key Largo
- Pines and Palms Resort (4.5★), Islamorada
- Amara Cay Resort (4.4★), Islamorada
- Bayside Villas by Islander Resort (4.4★), Islamorada
Bayside Villas by Islander Resort
Resort hotel · Hotel
81450 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada
(305) 664-0082
4.4
website
Sea Dwellers Dive Center of Key Largo
SCUBA tour agency · Boat tour agency · Dive shop
522 Caribbean Dr, Key Largo
(305) 451-3640
4.8
Popular place
website
Paradise Island Charters
Boat tour agency · Hotel · SCUBA tour agency
105 Laguna Ave E5, Key Largo
(305) 451-3640
4.9
website
Pines and Palms Resort
Resort hotel
80401 Old Hwy, Islamorada
(305) 664-4343
4.5
website
Amara Cay Resort
Resort hotel · Hotel · Restaurant
80001 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada
(888) 317-0889
4.4
Popular place
website
Kona Kai Resort, Gallery and Botanic Gardens
Resort hotel · Art gallery · Botanical garden
97802 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo
(305) 852-7200
4.9
website
Th
The Beachside Resident
editorial answer · from the site’s listings
Similar questions
1answer
Which is nicer, Destin or Fort Walton Beach?
Town vs town
Destin Frequently asked
1answer
Which beach is nicer, St. Pete or Clearwater?
Town vs town
St. Petersburg Frequently asked
1answer
Which beach is nicer, Pensacola or Destin?
Town vs town
Pensacola Frequently asked
1answer
Which is nicer, St. Pete's beach or Clearwater?
Town vs town
St. Petersburg Frequently asked
1answer
Which is better, Port Charlotte or Punta Gorda?
Town vs town
Port Charlotte Frequently asked