Which is better to stay in, Key Largo or Key West?

Key Largo 1 answer Oct 13, 2026

1 answer

In short

Going by the ratings of the hotels and inns in our listings, Key West edges it: its top three average 4.93★ against 4.87★ in Key Largo. Key Largo has 28 hotels and inns listed, Key West has 71.

Best rated on each side:

Kona Kai Resort, Gallery and Botanic Gardens (4.9★), Key Largo
Sea Dwellers Dive Center of Key Largo (4.8★), Key Largo
Paradise Island Charters (4.9★), Key Largo
The Gardens Hotel (4.9★), Key West
Andrews Inn & Garden Cottages (5.0★), Key West
Alexander's Guesthouse-Adult Exclusive (4.9★), Key West

Alexander's Guesthouse-Adult Exclusive

Guest house · Bed & breakfast

1118 Fleming St, Key West (305) 294-9919

4.9

Popular place website

The Gardens Hotel

Hotel · Bed & breakfast · Wine bar

526 Angela St, Key West (305) 294-2661

4.9

website

Sea Dwellers Dive Center of Key Largo

SCUBA tour agency · Boat tour agency · Dive shop

522 Caribbean Dr, Key Largo (305) 451-3640

4.8

Popular place website

Paradise Island Charters

Boat tour agency · Hotel · SCUBA tour agency

105 Laguna Ave E5, Key Largo (305) 451-3640

4.9

website

Andrews Inn & Garden Cottages

Hotel · Bed & breakfast · Guest house

223 Eanes Ln, Key West (305) 294-7730

5.0

website

Kona Kai Resort, Gallery and Botanic Gardens

Resort hotel · Art gallery · Botanical garden

97802 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo (305) 852-7200

4.9

website

The Beachside Resident editorial answer · from the site’s listings

Which is better to stay in, Key Largo or Key West?

1 answer

Your answer

Similar questions